I need a better skin care routine?

Scrap the Avon! Use Burt's Bees instead. It is very gentle on the face and will keep you from breaking out in the future and keep your skin healthy if you ever go through periods when your skin is dry or sensitive. I would use a natural, plant-based cleanser from their website, such as the Radiance cleanser, followed by their Natural Acne Solutions Toner, then a good moisturizer that does not clog your pores. I know this sounds like many steps, but it's good stuff for what you pay and how long it lasts, and once you go natural, I can almost guarantee you won't go back to synthetics and chemicals!